Not ruling out some stange bacterial life that's generating phosphene however. Come on space agencies, Venus atmosphere sample mission when?
6
Agent641 @lemmy.world - 1.0yr
Well no. By definition it had Venus-like life.
6
muhyb @programming.dev - 1.0yr
Zoidberg:
-If you call that living.
2
qyron - 1.0yr
Earth-like would be, by definition, impossible. Venus-like, that, would be something.
4
remotelove @lemmy.ca - 1.0yr
Earth-like is a very broad term. If an organism has something similar to DNA or shared any kind of chemical processes it could be "earth-like".
As an odd hypothetical example, there is a theory that fungi could potentially spread from planet to planet. Even with a billion or so years of independent evolution, fungi on Venus and fungi on Earth could still share some of the same traits.
4
qyron - 1.0yr
Nobody caught the dad joke vibe, I see.
2
remotelove @lemmy.ca - 1.0yr
It was overshadowed by the first bit where you said "by definition, impossible". It kinda boned the delivery, TBH.
2
qyron - 1.0yr
Some you win, some you lose.
3
acockworkorange - 1.0yr
Some were born to sing the blues
1
qyron - 1.0yr
Which is a genre I enjoy very much.
1
acockworkorange - 1.0yr
Don’t stop believing
Hold on to that feeling
Streetlight people
1
NuraShiny [any] - 1.0yr
Well duh. It's a hell of acid storms and sulfur, how would it have had life?
3
HubertManne - 1.0yr
I mean sulfur is an important component of life and extremeophiles can handle many conditions. When I heard things about possible life at venus it was generally the idea of microorganisms floating in the atmosphere.
3
acockworkorange - 1.0yr
Even if it doesn’t have now, it’s quite a leap to say it never had.
1
NuraShiny [any] - 1.0yr
Is it? Why?
1
acockworkorange - 1.0yr
Earth was very inhospitable for life for quite some time. In the future, it could become barren again. What’s to say that Venus wasn’t once harboring life? We don’t know anywhere near enough of its geology to even guess that.
1
TheWolfOfSouthEnd @lemmygrad.ml - 1.0yr
I’m not meaning to sound sarcastic or like I’m taking the piss, but how do we know there are no life forms that like acid storms and sulphur?
1
NuraShiny [any] - 1.0yr
This headline says earth-like life. I just didn't repeat the word.
2
huf [he/him] - 1.0yr
there's a bunch of life around the deep sea volcanoes that lives off sulphur and stuff, so technically it'd still be earth-like life :)
fossilesque in astronomy
Atmospheric analysis shows Venus never had Earth-like life, scientists say
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2024/dec/02/venus-life-water-atmosphere-analysis-science-researchI can't say I'm surprised
...But my relief is profound
Not ruling out some stange bacterial life that's generating phosphene however. Come on space agencies, Venus atmosphere sample mission when?
Well no. By definition it had Venus-like life.
Zoidberg:
-If you call that living.
Earth-like would be, by definition, impossible. Venus-like, that, would be something.
Earth-like is a very broad term. If an organism has something similar to DNA or shared any kind of chemical processes it could be "earth-like".
As an odd hypothetical example, there is a theory that fungi could potentially spread from planet to planet. Even with a billion or so years of independent evolution, fungi on Venus and fungi on Earth could still share some of the same traits.
Nobody caught the dad joke vibe, I see.
It was overshadowed by the first bit where you said "by definition, impossible". It kinda boned the delivery, TBH.
Some you win, some you lose.
Some were born to sing the blues
Which is a genre I enjoy very much.
Don’t stop believing
Hold on to that feeling
Streetlight people
Well duh. It's a hell of acid storms and sulfur, how would it have had life?
I mean sulfur is an important component of life and extremeophiles can handle many conditions. When I heard things about possible life at venus it was generally the idea of microorganisms floating in the atmosphere.
Even if it doesn’t have now, it’s quite a leap to say it never had.
Is it? Why?
Earth was very inhospitable for life for quite some time. In the future, it could become barren again. What’s to say that Venus wasn’t once harboring life? We don’t know anywhere near enough of its geology to even guess that.
I’m not meaning to sound sarcastic or like I’m taking the piss, but how do we know there are no life forms that like acid storms and sulphur?
This headline says earth-like life. I just didn't repeat the word.
there's a bunch of life around the deep sea volcanoes that lives off sulphur and stuff, so technically it'd still be earth-like life :)
Fair point there!