Informal Site Survey: Are you transgender or gender diverse? Yes, no, or maybe?
Hey, we haven't been able to find a secure way to poll everyone yet, and I've really been itching to ask everyone this question so we can get updated numbers on our trans population here. This isn't going to be scientific or anything, but just a quick guess.
Please respond to this post with a 'yes', 'no', or 'maybe'. If you have anything to add, please use a spoiler tag below your answer like so:
::: spoiler spoiler
hi!
:::
Remember to respond even if you are cis.
Erika3sis [she/her, xe/xem] - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler spoiler
Sometimes I doubt myself, but then I remember that when I was at an org meeting a while back and one of my comrades took out her estro tablets, my mouth kinda watered a bit, and then I think about going back to my old name and I'm like actually no I prefer the new one
:::
35
booty [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
::: spoiler spoiler
is this some kind of honeypot to ban all cis people? because i support it if so
:::
34
Kaputnik [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
but a fan of the emotes
33
Elon_Musk [none/use name] - 2.3yr
No, but vaxxed
31
Finger [he/him] - 2.3yr
no more half measures walter
31
zifnab25 [he/him, any] - 2.3yr
I am the most cis het middle aged white man you will ever meet.
Still have nothing but love and respect for my Trans Comrades.
28
WhyEssEff [she/her] - 2.3yr
::: spoiler yes
i havent made any effort to transition due to cowardice but I'm like 95% sure
:::
28
the_itsb [she/her, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
Maybe? Would have said No a year ago, but I chopped all my hair off last spring and have been wearing less feminine clothes and have been wondering lately if my decades of super-femme presentation was another form of masking.
Idk, this question has come at a time that I'm questioning myself.
28
corgiwithalaptop [any, love/loves] - 2.3yr
Maybe
::: spoiler details
Agender - ive chatted with some users here and they have said it falls under that umbrella, but not something i think deep about often. :::
24
Rod_Blagojevic [none/use name] - 2.3yr
No, but I've received a ton of vaccines and eat a ton of tofu.
24
jack [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No I'm a cissy
22
SexUnderSocialism [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
Nice try
:::
21
EmmaGoldman [she/her, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No but yes but maybe?
I'm intersex, but don't ID as trans.
20
axont [she/her, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
I'm nonbinary. Communism will win, death to Israel, death to America inshallah.
:::
20
Ho_Chi_Chungus [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler spoiler
but still very new at this
:::
19
PM_ME_VINTAGE_30S [he/him] - 2.3yr
No, I'm here to listen.
19
nemoTheCatfish [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
::: spoiler i would say no
I've been thinking about this some recently after doing some reading... and more and more I'm recognizing that the enforced gender binary is bullshit and bad for us, all of us. Like @Infamousblt@hexbear.net I've benefitted from many privileges being a cishet man and think basic male culture is especially bad and would like to distance myself from it when I can. But I don't really feel like I issues with my body. I've wanted to paint my nails and think that kilts should make a comeback. But I never thought of that of anything other than a different sense of style. Given all of that it really feels like I'd be stealing trans valor if I were to go "I'm gonna present like a normie cis dude but declare myself nonbinary for political reasons." I was going to make a post about this at some point so thank you for the opportunity. I accept being a part of the cis-purge if that's the plan lmao
Either way
:::
18
AernaLingus [any] - 2.3yr
Maybe
::: spoiler spoiler
Every time I look at https://genderdysphoria.fyi/ or w/e I get too spooked and then just try to shove all the thoughts into a dusty corner of my brain. Definitely normal cis behavior, nothing to see here
:::
18
kristina [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
:::
18
Kuori [she/her, pup/pup's] - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler spoiler
whew! finally finished upbearing everyone who said maybe or yes.
:::
17
silent_water [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
17
UmbraVivi [he/him, she/her] - 2.3yr
maybe
17
ashinadash [she/her] - 2.3yr
::: spoiler Yes!
I began transing my gender almost a decade ago & I think anyone who's interested should give it a try! Maybe do not start by just "going fulltime" in highschool and yelling at anyone who refers to you incorrectly, though, lmao.
I'm hoping for over 50% non-cis responses tbh, I think we can do it. The bear website is beautiful, I just know it.
Edit: I sometimes wonder about the site culture being overwhelmingly transfem, so I am pleased to see many more transmasc commenters here than I expected.
:::
17
iie [none/use name] - 2.3yr
Yes, closeted enby, no idea what to do about it
16
Infamousblt [any] - 2.3yr
Maybe?
::: spoiler spoiler
I look cis and present cis and get all of the privilege of being cis most of the time but I think "man" is meh and I don't like it for myself really because most of the time other men are not anything like who I want to be or see myself as. If all the other men in the world were more like me and less like how they are I'd be totally cool with man. But since they kinda suck and I kinda don't want to suck I don't feel like a man. I don't see much of myself in most other men. Also if someone refers to me as a gender other than man or uses pronouns other than he/him I feel totally fine with it and kinda like it sometimes. Love being counted as one of the theys when all my theys count me as one of them but I don't really feel like a they that often either. So I dunno. I'm still trying to figure it out but have been for years and haven't figured it out yet.
So count that as you will. A weak maybe by some pretty loose definitions of trans but if that's not maybe enough I won't be hurt at all if you're like "oh one of those dudes" and mark me down as cis.
:::
16
D61 [any] - 2.3yr
Nonbinary gender identities
If you’re trying to get a handle on what it means to be nonbinary, you’re going to have to get comfortable in gray space: There are no specific, hard-and-fast rules about nonbinary identities or “what it means” to be nonbinary.
Maybe?
16
gaycomputeruser [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
16
good_girl [she/her, they/them] - 2.3yr
yes
15
Acute_Engles [he/him, any] - 2.3yr
No. I have really thought about it because i frequent a lot of leftist and therefore trans spaces. I am 100% cis in so far as gender exists.
15
Babs [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
:::
15
regularassbitch [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
15
queermunist she/her - 2.3yr
::: spoiler Yes
Kinda late (started transitioning at 29 lol) but I got there!
And it could happen to youuuu!
:::
15
JohannaChittarra - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler spoiler
down with cis
:::
15
RION [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes, I think/hope
14
SootySootySoot [any] - 2.3yr
::: spoiler Maybe.
I kind of consider myself as not having a gender, but also I don't typically identify with people who typically identify as 'agender' so go figure.
::: spoiler Also
it's really hard to figure out how spoilers work. Something about three colons, then the word spoiler, then newlines? I still don't get it. Include a tutorial :(
14
GunslingerSky [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
14
lapis [fae/faer, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler spoiler
low-key impressed by the ability of people to ignore the instructions in the OP and just write long comments anyways
:::
14
khizuo [ze/zir] - 2.3yr
Yes
14
JoeByeThen [he/him, they/them] - 2.3yr
No.
14
WIIHAPPYFEW [any, any] - 2.3yr
Yes (masc genderfluid)
14
Washburn [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
14
anothertranscomrade [they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
13
Water Bowl Slime - 2.3yr
::: spoiler Maybe?
I am what I am because it's the social default not because I identify with it. I don't care to change though so does that make me cis? Or some type of agender? idk
:::
13
casskaydee [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
Extremely
:::
13
aen [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
13
alexandra_kollontai [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes!
13
Hohsia [any] - 2.3yr
I have no idea what I am
13
Wake [she/her, they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
13
Cromalin [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
13
TheDeed [he/him] - 2.3yr
yes
13
melon_popsicle [none/use name] - 2.3yr
maybe
13
vertexarray [any] - 2.3yr
yes
13
gramxi [they/them] - 2.3yr
yes
12
SnowySkyes - 2.3yr
Yes
12
AutomatedPossum [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
12
FumpyAer [any, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
Maybe.
I've been mulling it over and I'm experimenting with peripherally fem stuff (longer, bigger hair, earrings, women's blouses/shirts, might fuck around with dresses this summer) but also I'm trying to increase my strength and muscle size and become a himbo and all of those things seem gender affirming and self affirming.
I'm aware that many of the above things aren't necessarily strongly gendered (women can build muscle, men can have long hair, etc etc). But it's been kinda freeing to make the jump to some women's cut garments.
12
Dessa [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
12
ShimmeringKoi [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
I don't think so, unless gender apathetic is a thing
12
SoyViking [he/him] - 2.3yr
No.
::: spoiler spoiler
Maybe a little bit at times but not really. I feel fine about being a cis man but I also feel that if I had a magic button that would turn me into a woman for a couple of hours I would press it once in a while, just to get some of that experience as well.
I feel that some of it is due to all the things that sucks about patriarchal gender roles. A break from some of the bullshit that is part of masculinity could be nice. I know women have their own bullshit as well but at least it would be different bullshit.
:::
12
da_gay_pussy_eatah [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler Title
Hell yeah 😎
:::
12
IMF_DOOM [she/her] - 2.3yr
Double yes
12
RedQuestionAsker2 [he/him, she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
Gender diverse
:::
12
Zuzak [fae/faer, she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
11
blakeus12 [he/him] - 2.3yr
no, sorry
11
infuziSporg [e/em/eir] - 2.3yr
Maybe?
:::spoiler details
Assigned and socialized male, never had huge problems with it but I did get frustrated with all pressures to perform any kind of masculinity. By my early 20s, probably the majority of my physical and social characteristics are gender-ambiguous. To this day I like it that way, I see myself as "somewhere in-between", and I get euphoria when young children ask me the "are you a boy or a girl" question. The first time I voiced any preference for eh/em pronouns was like 7 years ago, but I don't make a big deal of it. I don't think I really understand gender in myself and most of my experience of it is an experience of exclusion. I do understand gender in others and am attracted to femmes and enbies. My queer friends all say I'm queer-coded, but I doubt that this fits, or maybe I'm a self-deprecating enby.
I just don't want anybody to be boxed into a category that they didn't want to be in.
:::
11
asg101 [none/use name, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No, 100% satisfied with factory settings.
11
hello_hello [undecided, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
maybe
11
Septimaeus @infosec.pub - 2.3yr
Yes
11
Rx_Hawk [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
::: spoiler spoiler
I guess I say no here. I present masc, and definitely lean that way, but I've come to realize that a lot more people are gender fluid than think they are, myself included. It's all kind of silly how we get drilled into our heads what we are supposed to be and how we're supposed to act, when we are all our own unique individuals.
:::
11
TerminalEncounter [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
10
odmroz [he/him] - 2.3yr
Yes
10
wtypstanaccount04 [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
::: spoiler More info
I have asked myself this question many times, and the answer is still no. Probably the most gender diverse thing I have done is have an anime girl pfp, but on the other hand that's a very cis thing to do too.
:::
10
CDommunist [she/her, love/loves] - 2.3yr
Yes Yes
I'm voting yes twice to cancel out somebody saying no
Sometimes I want both parts like I have both "in me". I feel more happy when I don't have to put on the mask of being "man". I'm more happy being womanly. Fantazise, but I'm ok with being a male save balding, stupid facial hair that I have to manage constantly and circumcised. I think circumcision took something from me. I wish I could have sensitivity in my nipples.
I've always said to my family I'm "half woman" kind of as a quip to excuse my femine side, but I identify more male.
I don't know if that's eggish or fluid or what not, but it isn't like I have dysmorphia about insisting on being a woman. I didn't have those issues through puberty with my gender. AFIK I'm cis gay male.
:::
10
EllenKelly [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
yes
10
Pisha [she/her, they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
10
ritalin [they/them, she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
10
Kiwi - 2.3yr
Cis
::: spoiler bonus
2017 to 2020 I identified as trans, then identified as a femboy until about 2022/3 where I now just identify as myself. I'm still in touch with my feminine side tho. I'm also bi
:::
::: spoiler although...
It's more like a No to maybe, but i don't feel like i've come to a conclusion that's meaningfully different from bog-standard cis man enough to say anything but No
:::
::: spoiler spoiler
I feel pretty nonbinary and close to lots of trans issues but I also feel like I am day to day presenting as a cis male so I always feel like I am co-opting trans culture. Also I don't know if I spoiler tagged this right
:::
9
iridaniotter [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
9
wheresmysurplusvalue [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No
9
LesbianLiberty [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
8
imogen_underscore [it/its, she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
8
pacifist [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
8
Awoo [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
8
NephewAlphaBravo [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
::: spoiler spoiler
i've had hella long hair my entire adult life though, it rules
:::
Maybe
::: spoiler spoiler
I’m not really sure what I identify as, kinda wish I could just snap my fingers and look like a man or woman at will idk
:::
8
PerryBot4000 [she/her, he/him] - 2.3yr
Maybe
8
PapaEmeritusIII [any] - 2.3yr
yes
8
Alisu [she/her, they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes i am trans
8
Moss [they/them] - 2.3yr
yes!!!
7
robinn_IV - 2.3yr
no
7
aaaaaaadjsf [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No
7
FourteenEyes [he/him] - 2.3yr
Nope!
7
Mister_Bennet [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
7
JustSo [she/her, any] - 2.3yr
Yes.
7
ButtBidet [he/him] - 2.3yr
No sadly
7
largerfather [he/him] - 2.3yr
respond even if *your cis
no
7
thirtymilliondeadfish [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
7
Crucible [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No
7
lurker_supreme [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
7
DengistDonnieDarko [none/use name] - 2.3yr
::: spoiler No
Infinite love to my trans comrades
:::
7
Sodium_nitride @lemmygrad.ml - 2.3yr
I'm just confused 😕
7
tetrabrick [xey/xem, she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
7
TBooneChickens [she/her, she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler spoiler
transfem non-binary. still rather uncertain about identity, but the key tenets so far seem to be: reject man, embrace femininity. visible transfolk helped me realize my transness, including some here 💕
No.
But a very soft no because I think I'd like being a woman just as well but pretty sure It's not reflective of gender that I present or feel? But no accounting at the moment should count me as gender diverse lol
7
ProfessorAdonisCnut [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
7
BountifulEggnog [it/its, she/her] - 2.3yr
No
::: spoiler spoiler
I'm living as a cis guy, so ig I'm not, but I've been toying with the idea. I don't necessarily want to be seen as a guy and if I could press a button to be born different, I'd definitely give it a long think. But a maybe seems like it'd be giving me too much credit.
:::
7
Ocommie63 [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
7
Pluto [he/him, he/him] - 2.3yr
I may be genderqueer.
I am Autistic and probably autigender.
I have been questioning lately.
7
Aliveelectricwire [it/its, she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
7
PsychedSy @lemmy.dbzer0.com - 2.3yr
Maybe, but little enough to probably say no.
I'm ostensibly straight and cis, and looking at my life you'd mostly assume that.
I have never felt super masculine, but that could be caught up with anxiety/ASD/ADHD shit. I've never felt like I belonged, so it's kind of hard to assess.
7
ReadFanon [any, any] - 2.3yr
Yes
7
TrashGoblin [he/him, they/them] - 2.3yr
maybe
::: spoiler spoiler
I pondered this heavily when I was introduced to TF media in my late 20s and early 30s. Came out with the decision that I'm a mildly gender nonconforming cis man. I don't feel any gender very strongly, but I don't know if that's just because masculinity is 'unmarked' in the culture I live in.
:::
7
Lenins_Cat_Reincarnated - 2.3yr
Yes
7
companero [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
7
combat_brandonism [they/them] - 2.3yr
yes
::: spoiler spoiler
posting this in traaa will probably skew results to yes
:::
7
Gay_Tomato [they/them, it/its] - 2.3yr
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
Im some kind of genderfluid. (Is that what gender diverse is supposed to cover?)
:::
7
macerated_baby_presidents [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
6
IHATESMOKINGCHRONIC [any] - 2.3yr
Abstain
6
SeventyTwoTrillion [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
MF_COOM [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
FunkyStuff [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
Leoncio [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
6
Thordros [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No.
6
Sphere [he/him, they/them] - 2.3yr
No
6
dualmindblade [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
Nomisslehere [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
ChestRockwell [comrade/them, any] - 2.3yr
No
6
anarchoilluminati [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
Nope, cis.
6
Weedian [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
::: spoiler spoiler
But I love you all
:::
6
batsforpeace [any, any] - 2.3yr
no
6
Red_Sunshine_Over_Florida [he/him] - 2.3yr
No.
6
Chapo_is_Red [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
TC_209 [he/him, pup/pup's] - 2.3yr
No.
6
Katlah - 2.3yr
yes
6
tuckar_clarnos [she/her,they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
6
barrbaric [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
vehicom @lemmygrad.ml - 2.3yr
maybe
6
NailBunny [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes, I'm transfem. I huff E recreationally just to feel something
::: spoiler spoiler
most people identify me as male but I don't care about gender and use any and all pronouns so there's generally nothing to 'correct', so not many people realise I'm not a binary man
:::
6
Are_Euclidding_Me [e/em/eir] - 2.3yr
yes
6
edge [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
::: spoiler spoiler
More like “probably not” or “not exactly”. I don’t really like the word “man” for myself. “Boy” is nice for some reason. I think I have some “Peter Pan syndrome” thing. I really would rather be a kid and am kind of depressed that I just can’t anymore. But all of that feelsadjacent to the things I’ve seen trans and nb people say about their gender.
I read about an NB person who wanted to stay on puberty blockers indefinitely, and honestly I think I would have liked that. Maybe like a couple years after puberty started though.
I’ve seen terms like “demiboy” and I think “yeah maybe, but not exactly”. Femboy isn’t really a gender but I’d love to be one.
But regardless of all that, I still consider myself a cis male, because “boy” is just a type of male anyway.
Gender non-conforming is a good general label IMO that I kind of want to be but don’t really feel like I’m pulling off right now (not that I’ve tried all that much). I much prefer not having a beard, but shaving is so much work and I don’t have much experience.
:::
6
VHS [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
6
AOCapitulator [they/them, she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
6
Kaplya - 2.3yr
haha, before Hexbear: no
After Chapo.chat/Hexbear: almost a yes? i guess?
6
space_comrade [he/him] - 2.3yr
No.
6
SteamedHamberder [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
EndOfHerstory [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes!
5
Mindfury [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
5
autism_2 [any, it/its] - 2.3yr
yes
5
farting_weedman [none/use name] - 2.3yr
No
5
PaulSmackage [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No?
5
WhatDoYouMeanPodcast [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No
5
Frogmanfromlake [none/use name] - 2.3yr
No
5
dragongloss [she/her, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
yes
5
Wakmrow [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
neo [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
Tommasi [she/her, pup/pup's] - 2.3yr
yes
5
DerRedMax [comrade/them, any] - 2.3yr
Yes
5
nathanfieldertulpa [she/her, it/its] - 2.3yr
yes
5
python [undecided, they/them] - 2.3yr
maybe
5
CptKrkIsClmbngThMntn [any] - 2.3yr
maybe
5
drinkinglakewater [he/him] - 2.3yr
Maybe
5
Pixel_Juicer [they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
5
homhom9000 [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
5
Crowtee_Robot [he/him, they/them] - 2.3yr
No
5
Philosoraptor [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No.
5
psychoplantkiller [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
5
Alaskaball [comrade/them, any] - 2.3yr
Likely not, no.
5
OnlyTrueLiberal [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
no
5
thelastaxolotl [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
viva_la_juche [they/them, any] - 2.3yr
yeh
5
TheLepidopterists [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
Alizarin [she/her, des/pair] - 2.3yr
Maybe
::: spoiler spoiler
Idk I'm avoiding the question
:::
5
blipblip [they/them] - 2.3yr
maybe
5
Facky [he/him,comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No
5
abc [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No.
::: spoiler spoiler
But I love my trans & gender diverse comrades!!
:::
5
SoloboiNanook [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No. Though I do occasionally wear makeup or women's clothes I find fashionable (pants, purses, etc). Don't think that really counts lol
5
nurjahreszeiten [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
5
frankfurt_schoolgirl [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
5
PorkrollPosadist [he/him, they/them] - 2.3yr
no
5
Abracadaniel [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
m532 [she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
5
dead [he/him] - 2.3yr
no
5
sharedburdens [she/her, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
Yes!
5
RacoonVegetable @reddthat.com - 2.3yr
no
5
comrade_pibb [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No
5
ZestyDwarf [he/him,comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No
5
RedWizard [he/him, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
No.
5
TeddyKila [comrade/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
5
anaesidemus [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
Thorngraff_Ironbeard [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
5
NoYouLogOff [he/him, they/them] - 2.3yr
No
4
SpookyVanguard64 [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
4
Florn [they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
4
Aquilae [he/him, they/them] - 2.3yr
No
4
JosephinaStalin [they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
4
1000mH [she/her, they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
4
stevatoo [they/them, she/her] - 2.3yr
Yes
4
babushkot [they/them] - 2.3yr
Yes
4
roux [they/them, xe/xem] - 2.3yr
Am cis.
4
citrussy_capybara [ze/hir] - 2.3yr
yes
4
imikoy [she/her, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
yes
4
violet [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
4
Łumało [he/him] - 2.3yr
No :3
4
CharlieTheOctopus [he/him] - 2.3yr
No
4
JamesConeZone [they/them] - 2.3yr
No
4
Anxious_Anarchist [they/them, any] - 2.3yr
Yes
4
RussianEngineer [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
4
sovietknuckles [she/her] - 2.3yr
yes
4
DBVegas [any, comrade/them] - 2.3yr
Yeh genderfluid specifically
4
girl_liker - 2.3yr
Yes
4
QueerCommie [she/her, fae/faer] - 2.3yr
Yes. You could’ve done this poll better (three comments, people upvote the one that applies).
kristina in traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns
Informal Site Survey: Are you transgender or gender diverse? Yes, no, or maybe?
Hey, we haven't been able to find a secure way to poll everyone yet, and I've really been itching to ask everyone this question so we can get updated numbers on our trans population here. This isn't going to be scientific or anything, but just a quick guess.
Please respond to this post with a 'yes', 'no', or 'maybe'. If you have anything to add, please use a spoiler tag below your answer like so:
::: spoiler spoiler hi! :::
Remember to respond even if you are cis.
yes
::: spoiler spoiler Sometimes I doubt myself, but then I remember that when I was at an org meeting a while back and one of my comrades took out her estro tablets, my mouth kinda watered a bit, and then I think about going back to my old name and I'm like actually no I prefer the new one :::
no
::: spoiler spoiler is this some kind of honeypot to ban all cis people? because i support it if so
:::
No
No, but vaxxed
no
more half measures walterI am the most cis het middle aged white man you will ever meet.
Still have nothing but love and respect for my Trans Comrades.
::: spoiler yes i havent made any effort to transition due to cowardice but I'm like 95% sure :::
Maybe? Would have said No a year ago, but I chopped all my hair off last spring and have been wearing less feminine clothes and have been wondering lately if my decades of super-femme presentation was another form of masking.
Idk, this question has come at a time that I'm questioning myself.
Maybe
::: spoiler details
Agender - ive chatted with some users here and they have said it falls under that umbrella, but not something i think deep about often. :::
No, but I've received a ton of vaccines and eat a ton of tofu.
No I'm a cissy
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler Nice try
:::
No but yes but maybe?
I'm intersex, but don't ID as trans.
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler I'm nonbinary. Communism will win, death to Israel, death to America inshallah. :::
yes
::: spoiler spoiler but still very new at this
:::
No, I'm here to listen.
::: spoiler i would say no I've been thinking about this some recently after doing some reading... and more and more I'm recognizing that the enforced gender binary is bullshit and bad for us, all of us. Like @Infamousblt@hexbear.net I've benefitted from many privileges being a cishet man and think basic male culture is especially bad and would like to distance myself from it when I can. But I don't really feel like I issues with my body. I've wanted to paint my nails and think that kilts should make a comeback. But I never thought of that of anything other than a different sense of style. Given all of that it really feels like I'd be stealing trans valor if I were to go "I'm gonna present like a normie cis dude but declare myself nonbinary for political reasons." I was going to make a post about this at some point so thank you for the opportunity. I accept being a part of the cis-purge if that's the plan lmao
Either way
:::
Maybe
::: spoiler spoiler Every time I look at https://genderdysphoria.fyi/ or w/e I get too spooked and then just try to shove all the thoughts into a dusty corner of my brain. Definitely normal cis behavior, nothing to see here
:::
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
:::
yes ::: spoiler spoiler whew! finally finished upbearing everyone who said maybe or yes. :::
yes
maybe
::: spoiler Yes! I began transing my gender almost a decade ago & I think anyone who's interested should give it a try! Maybe do not start by just "going fulltime" in highschool and yelling at anyone who refers to you incorrectly, though, lmao.
I'm hoping for over 50% non-cis responses tbh, I think we can do it. The bear website is beautiful, I just know it.
Edit: I sometimes wonder about the site culture being overwhelmingly transfem, so I am pleased to see many more transmasc commenters here than I expected.
:::
Yes, closeted enby, no idea what to do about it
Maybe? ::: spoiler spoiler I look cis and present cis and get all of the privilege of being cis most of the time but I think "man" is meh and I don't like it for myself really because most of the time other men are not anything like who I want to be or see myself as. If all the other men in the world were more like me and less like how they are I'd be totally cool with man. But since they kinda suck and I kinda don't want to suck I don't feel like a man. I don't see much of myself in most other men. Also if someone refers to me as a gender other than man or uses pronouns other than he/him I feel totally fine with it and kinda like it sometimes. Love being counted as one of the theys when all my theys count me as one of them but I don't really feel like a they that often either. So I dunno. I'm still trying to figure it out but have been for years and haven't figured it out yet.
So count that as you will. A weak maybe by some pretty loose definitions of trans but if that's not maybe enough I won't be hurt at all if you're like "oh one of those dudes" and mark me down as cis. :::
Maybe?
yes
yes
No. I have really thought about it because i frequent a lot of leftist and therefore trans spaces. I am 100% cis in so far as gender exists.
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler
:::
yes
::: spoiler Yes Kinda late (started transitioning at 29 lol) but I got there!
And it could happen to youuuu! :::
yes
::: spoiler spoiler down with cis :::
Yes, I think/hope
::: spoiler Maybe. I kind of consider myself as not having a gender, but also I don't typically identify with people who typically identify as 'agender' so go figure.
::: spoiler Also it's really hard to figure out how spoilers work. Something about three colons, then the word spoiler, then newlines? I still don't get it. Include a tutorial :(
Yes
yes
::: spoiler spoiler low-key impressed by the ability of people to ignore the instructions in the OP and just write long comments anyways :::
Yes
No.
Yes (masc genderfluid)
yes
Yes
::: spoiler Maybe? I am what I am because it's the social default not because I identify with it. I don't care to change though so does that make me cis? Or some type of agender? idk :::
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler Extremely :::
no
yes!
I have no idea what I am
Yes
yes
yes
maybe
yes
yes
Yes
Yes
Maybe.
I've been mulling it over and I'm experimenting with peripherally fem stuff (longer, bigger hair, earrings, women's blouses/shirts, might fuck around with dresses this summer) but also I'm trying to increase my strength and muscle size and become a himbo and all of those things seem gender affirming and self affirming.
I'm aware that many of the above things aren't necessarily strongly gendered (women can build muscle, men can have long hair, etc etc). But it's been kinda freeing to make the jump to some women's cut garments.
Yes
I don't think so, unless gender apathetic is a thing
No.
::: spoiler spoiler
Maybe a little bit at times but not really. I feel fine about being a cis man but I also feel that if I had a magic button that would turn me into a woman for a couple of hours I would press it once in a while, just to get some of that experience as well.
I feel that some of it is due to all the things that sucks about patriarchal gender roles. A break from some of the bullshit that is part of masculinity could be nice. I know women have their own bullshit as well but at least it would be different bullshit.
:::
yes
::: spoiler Title Hell yeah 😎 :::
Double yes
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler Gender diverse :::
Yes
no, sorry
Maybe?
:::spoiler details
Assigned and socialized male, never had huge problems with it but I did get frustrated with all pressures to perform any kind of masculinity. By my early 20s, probably the majority of my physical and social characteristics are gender-ambiguous. To this day I like it that way, I see myself as "somewhere in-between", and I get euphoria when young children ask me the "are you a boy or a girl" question. The first time I voiced any preference for eh/em pronouns was like 7 years ago, but I don't make a big deal of it. I don't think I really understand gender in myself and most of my experience of it is an experience of exclusion. I do understand gender in others and am attracted to femmes and enbies. My queer friends all say I'm queer-coded, but I doubt that this fits, or maybe I'm a self-deprecating enby.
I just don't want anybody to be boxed into a category that they didn't want to be in. :::
No, 100% satisfied with factory settings.
maybe
Yes
No
::: spoiler spoiler I guess I say no here. I present masc, and definitely lean that way, but I've come to realize that a lot more people are gender fluid than think they are, myself included. It's all kind of silly how we get drilled into our heads what we are supposed to be and how we're supposed to act, when we are all our own unique individuals. :::
Yes
Yes
No
::: spoiler More info I have asked myself this question many times, and the answer is still no. Probably the most gender diverse thing I have done is have an anime girl pfp, but on the other hand that's a very cis thing to do too. :::
Yes Yes
I'm voting yes twice to cancel out somebody saying no
yes
yes
Yes
Yes
It's in the name.
No
::: spoiler ish?
Sometimes I want both parts like I have both "in me". I feel more happy when I don't have to put on the mask of being "man". I'm more happy being womanly. Fantazise, but I'm ok with being a male save balding, stupid facial hair that I have to manage constantly and circumcised. I think circumcision took something from me. I wish I could have sensitivity in my nipples.
I've always said to my family I'm "half woman" kind of as a quip to excuse my femine side, but I identify more male.
I don't know if that's eggish or fluid or what not, but it isn't like I have dysmorphia about insisting on being a woman. I didn't have those issues through puberty with my gender. AFIK I'm cis gay male.
:::
yes
Yes
yes
Cis ::: spoiler bonus 2017 to 2020 I identified as trans, then identified as a femboy until about 2022/3 where I now just identify as myself. I'm still in touch with my feminine side tho. I'm also bi :::
yes
Maybe
No
No
Yes
yes
No
No
::: spoiler although... It's more like a No to maybe, but i don't feel like i've come to a conclusion that's meaningfully different from bog-standard cis man enough to say anything but No :::
Yes
yes
Yes
Cis+
Yes
Yes Maybe?
::: spoiler spoiler I feel pretty nonbinary and close to lots of trans issues but I also feel like I am day to day presenting as a cis male so I always feel like I am co-opting trans culture. Also I don't know if I spoiler tagged this right
:::
Yes
No
Yes
yes
No
Yes
no
::: spoiler spoiler i've had hella long hair my entire adult life though, it rules :::
yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Unfortunately, no.
yes
no
maybe
No
No
Maybe ::: spoiler spoiler I’m not really sure what I identify as, kinda wish I could just snap my fingers and look like a man or woman at will idk :::
Maybe
yes
Yes i am trans
yes!!!
no
No
Nope!
No
Yes.
No sadly
respond even if *your cis
no
yes
No
No
::: spoiler No Infinite love to my trans comrades
:::
I'm just confused 😕
yes
yes
::: spoiler spoiler transfem non-binary. still rather uncertain about identity, but the key tenets so far seem to be: reject man, embrace femininity. visible transfolk helped me realize my transness, including some here 💕
:::
No. But a very soft no because I think I'd like being a woman just as well but pretty sure It's not reflective of gender that I present or feel? But no accounting at the moment should count me as gender diverse lol
No
No
::: spoiler spoiler I'm living as a cis guy, so ig I'm not, but I've been toying with the idea. I don't necessarily want to be seen as a guy and if I could press a button to be born different, I'd definitely give it a long think. But a maybe seems like it'd be giving me too much credit. :::
Yes
I may be genderqueer.
I am Autistic and probably autigender.
I have been questioning lately.
Yes
Maybe, but little enough to probably say no.
I'm ostensibly straight and cis, and looking at my life you'd mostly assume that.
I have never felt super masculine, but that could be caught up with anxiety/ASD/ADHD shit. I've never felt like I belonged, so it's kind of hard to assess.
Yes
maybe
::: spoiler spoiler I pondered this heavily when I was introduced to TF media in my late 20s and early 30s. Came out with the decision that I'm a mildly gender nonconforming cis man. I don't feel any gender very strongly, but I don't know if that's just because masculinity is 'unmarked' in the culture I live in. :::
Yes
No
yes
::: spoiler spoiler posting this in traaa will probably skew results to yes :::
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler Im some kind of genderfluid. (Is that what gender diverse is supposed to cover?) :::
no
Abstain
No
No
No
no
No.
No
No
No
No
Nope, cis.
No
::: spoiler spoiler But I love you all :::
no
No.
No
No.
yes
Yes
No
maybe
Yes, I'm transfem. I huff E recreationally just to feel something
yes!
No
yes
Yes
yes
No
no
No, Im cis
Yes
Yes.
Maybe, probably not
no
yes
Yes
::: spoiler spoiler most people identify me as male but I don't care about gender and use any and all pronouns so there's generally nothing to 'correct', so not many people realise I'm not a binary man :::
yes
no
::: spoiler spoiler More like “probably not” or “not exactly”. I don’t really like the word “man” for myself. “Boy” is nice for some reason. I think I have some “Peter Pan syndrome” thing. I really would rather be a kid and am kind of depressed that I just can’t anymore. But all of that feels adjacent to the things I’ve seen trans and nb people say about their gender.
I read about an NB person who wanted to stay on puberty blockers indefinitely, and honestly I think I would have liked that. Maybe like a couple years after puberty started though.
I’ve seen terms like “demiboy” and I think “yeah maybe, but not exactly”. Femboy isn’t really a gender but I’d love to be one.
But regardless of all that, I still consider myself a cis male, because “boy” is just a type of male anyway.
Gender non-conforming is a good general label IMO that I kind of want to be but don’t really feel like I’m pulling off right now (not that I’ve tried all that much). I much prefer not having a beard, but shaving is so much work and I don’t have much experience. :::
No
Yes
haha, before Hexbear: no
After Chapo.chat/Hexbear: almost a yes? i guess?
No.
No
Yes!
no
yes
No
No?
No
No
yes
No
No
yes
Yes
yes
maybe
maybe
Maybe
Yes
Yes
No
No.
no
Likely not, no.
no
No
yeh
No
Maybe
::: spoiler spoiler Idk I'm avoiding the question :::
maybe
No
No.
::: spoiler spoiler
But I love my trans & gender diverse comrades!!
:::
No. Though I do occasionally wear makeup or women's clothes I find fashionable (pants, purses, etc). Don't think that really counts lol
no
yes
no
No
Yes
no
Yes!
no
No
No
No.
Yes
No
No
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Am cis.
yes
yes
yes
No :3
No
No
Yes
yes
yes
Yeh genderfluid specifically
Yes
Yes. You could’ve done this poll better (three comments, people upvote the one that applies).